Monday 18 February 2013

Portfolio Sale: Santander 10 3/8% Preference Shares (LSE:SAN)

I was 'conflicted', as they say in the US - but as dilemmas go, it was rather pleasant.

I bought the UK Santander's 10 3/8% Preference Shares just at the beginning of 2012, when I was cranking up the fixed-income element of my portfolio. At the time, this security was yielding 10% and was clearly a risky investment, given the level of turmoil in Euroland.
Fast forward to today and I am looking at an increase of 38% in capital value, but still with a ‘tasty’ current yield of around 7.7%: my earlier gamble on Spain has turned out well.

However, my home-grown ‘sell’ indicator is flashing and approaching '5', signifying that I have earned capital gains equivalent to nearly 5 years of income. That’s when I allow myself to think about selling - with the proviso that the yield is no longer attractive. But the problem is that the yield is still very good - and that was my dilemma.

Are there any other mitigating factors?

Essentially my purchase was a bit of a gamble on the stability of the Spanish and Eurozone financial system. Of course, Santander UK is a separate UK bank but if the Spanish parent - Banco Santander - were to get into trouble, I didn’t expect the UK branch to remain unscathed. And in that scenario, preference share holders suffer first.

Banco Santander is Spain’s biggest bank and I believe its destiny will be made in Spain, even though it has large (and apparently successful) banking activities in South America. But Spain is not doing at at all well: in the last three months of 2012 Spanish GDP contracted by 4% and is expected to slump again in 2013 as government cuts and a combination of high unemployment and declining wages undermine consumer and business spending. Total unemployment of 26% and, in particular, youth unemployment of over 50% is just not sustainable. What is more, a financial scandal implicating the government is brewing noisily: corruption at the top implies corruption further down the political food-chain - who knows what cracks are being papered over.

And how is Banco Santander weathering this storm in Spain? The picture is pretty bleak: in 2012 it made debt provisions of more than €18bn as the property downturn intensified and the number of toxic loans increased. As a result, the bank saw its profits collapse by almost 60% on the previous year to €2.1bn - not an insignificant amount of money (revenues from divisions in Latin America, Brazil and the UK have shored up profits) but when set against the provisions, it looks like they are in a hole and still digging.

And the news in the UK is not much better: Santander UK looks like being hit by the interest-rate-swap mis-selling scandal as well as payment insurance mis-selling.

Putting all that into my risk-assessment mix, I was less confident about Santander than when I bought a year ago. There is a difference between being skeptical of a Euro break-up and being wary of a thundering depression plus political turmoil in Spain. I’ve watched the rising price of my preference shares and it has stalled, so I’ve taken my chips off the table. And, as this was one of my largest holdings, I now have scope for some more currency and geographical diversification.

[Sale price: £1.25]

(An earlier version of this article appeared on Citywire Money)

I am not a financial adviser and the information provided does not constitute financial advice. You should always do your own research on top of what you learn here to ensure that it's right for your specific circumstances.


  1. Dear DIY,

    I'm new to this blog but find it very useful and plannng to build similar Income pyramid.
    One thing i noticed missing are Investment Trusts. Is their a reason for this ?
    I am also investigating IT's.

    1. Hi Anon,

      The fact is that I haven't yet found one I like - either because of the gearing, the fees or the management philosophy. But I'm open to being convinced.